Accountants Chester – Tax Tip No. 47
The High-Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC): Fair or Not?
The High-Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) attempts to recoup child benefit payments from higher-earning families. If either parent, or their partner, has an adjusted net income above £50,000, they face a tax charge. For every £100 of income exceeding £50,000, a 1% charge is levied on the total child benefit for that tax year. When income hits £60,000, the charge equals the entire benefit amount.
This can lead to complex situations. Couples might choose to stop receiving child benefit entirely. However, claiming even if it’s ultimately clawed back is crucial to secure National Insurance credits, especially if your income doesn’t otherwise qualify you for a full state pension year.
Accountants Chester – Check that Claimant
Understanding who the child benefit claimant is, versus who receives the payments, is vital. The claimant is the person who signed the initial claim form, and they can elect to have the benefit paid to another person. This might seem a trivial distinction for intact families, but it carries significant consequences if the couple separates.
Accountants Chester – The Meades Case: A Cautionary Tale
A recent case highlights the importance of reviewing child benefit claims upon separation. Mr. Meades was hit with a 2019/20 tax return amendment charging him HICBC. Here’s the story:
- 2012: Mr. Meades, married, claimed child benefit and elected to have it paid to his wife.
- 2017: The couple separated. Divorce was finalized in April 2019.
- 2019: Mr. Meades remarried, living year-round with his new spouse.
- Crucially, the child benefit claim was never revised for the separation.
Because he never relinquished his claimant status, Mr. Meades remained liable for HICBC, despite the benefit going to his ex-wife. The tribunal found HMRC’s assessment valid. The fact he financially supported his child, making him entitled to the benefit, further cemented his liability.
Accountants Chester – Lessons Learned & Strategies
- Separation Strategy: Review child benefit claims immediately in a separation. Had Mr. Meades relinquished his claim, allowing his ex-wife to become the claimant, his HICBC liability would have vanished.
- New Partner Considerations: If Mr. Meades’ new wife had both an income exceeding £50,000 and higher than his, she could’ve become liable for HICBC due to their marital status, despite the benefits going to his ex-wife!
Is HICBC Equitable?
The HICBC aims to redistribute resources, but it raises questions:
- Penalizing Support: Should parents continuing to financially support children, even indirectly, face charges designed for higher earners? Mr. Meades’ situation seems at odds with the intent.
- Complex Households: With blended families and multiple earners, liability can become a complex puzzle, highlighting the need for careful planning and awareness.
- Systemic Clarity: Many are unfamiliar with the “claimant” nuance, potentially facing unexpected tax bills as in the Meades case. Should HMRC take greater responsibility for communicating this distinction?
What Can You Do?
- Seek Professional Advice: Accountants and financial advisors can help navigate HICBC implications, especially if your household situation is complex.
- Review Child Benefit Status: If circumstances change (separation, new partner, income fluctuations), carefully consider if your child benefit position needs adjusting to avoid unintended charges.
- Stay Informed: Changes to HICBC thresholds and rules are possible. Keep abreast of updates to ensure your family isn’t caught off guard.
For more information, call or WhatsApp on +44(1244) 220-062 . Return to Tax Blog home.
Simplifying tax and accounting for Chester businesses – check out our FAQs for quick answers.
What is the high income benefit Child Benefit charge?
What is the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC)?
The High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) is a UK tax that aims to reclaim some or all of the Child Benefit payments received by families where one individual has an income exceeding £50,000.
How does it work?
- Income Threshold: The charge applies if you or your partner have an individual 'adjusted net income' over £50,000.
- Calculation: The charge is 1% of your family's Child Benefit for every £100 of income that exceeds the £50,000 threshold.
- Full Charge: If your income is over £60,000, the charge will equal the total amount of Child Benefit you receive.
Who pays the HICBC?
The person with the higher income in the household is responsible for paying the HICBC, regardless of who actually receives the Child Benefit payments. This is typically done through the Self Assessment tax return system.
Key Points to Remember
- Claiming Child Benefit: You can still claim Child Benefit even if you know you'll have to pay the charge. This is important to protect your child's National Insurance record and future State Pension entitlement.
- Adjusted Net Income: This figure may differ from your taxable income as it includes things like pension contributions and Gift Aid donations.
- Opting Out: You can choose to stop receiving Child Benefit payments to avoid the HICBC.
For further information and to use HMRC's online calculator to help you understand the potential charge, please visit: https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-charge
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
Is it worth claiming Child Benefit if you earn over 50k?
Understanding the System
- You still get the payments: If you have a child, you're entitled to Child Benefit regardless of your income.
- Higher earner pays: If one person in the household earns over £50,000 annually, the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) comes into play. This means you'll repay some, or all, of the Child Benefit via your Self Assessment tax return.
- Income over £60,000: If you earn over £60,000, you'll repay the entire amount you receive in Child Benefit.
Key Reasons to Claim
National Insurance (NI) Credits: Child Benefit helps protect your State Pension entitlement. You'll receive NI credits even if you're not working or earning below the NI threshold. This is crucial for a full State Pension later in life.
Flexibility: You can choose to stop receiving Child Benefit payments but still maintain the registration (and the NI benefits). If your income drops below £50,000 in the future, you can restart payments.
Things to Consider
- HICBC Calculator: Use the HMRC's Child Benefit tax calculator (https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-calculator) to work out how much you might need to repay.
- Income Fluctuations: If your income is close to the thresholds, it could fluctuate year-to-year, making claiming Child Benefit worthwhile.
In Summary
Even with the HICBC, there are strong reasons to claim Child Benefit. It's primarily about protecting your future State Pension entitlement.
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
What salary is too high for Child Benefit?
There isn't a salary level at which you become completely ineligible for Child Benefit. However, if you or your partner earns over £50,000 per year, you'll need to start repaying some of the Child Benefit you receive. This is known as the 'High Income Child Benefit Tax Charge'.
- How it works: The amount you have to repay increases gradually the more you earn over £50,000. For every £100 of income over this threshold, you repay 1% of your Child Benefit entitlement. If you or your partner earns over £60,000, you'll need to repay the full amount.
Important Note: The income threshold for starting repayments will rise to £60,000 on the 6th of April 2024.
Example:
- If you earn £55,000, you're £5,000 above the threshold.
- This means you'll pay back 50% of your Child Benefit.
Should I still claim Child Benefit even if I have to repay it?
It's usually worth claiming Child Benefit even if you'll later repay some or all of it. This is because it helps to:
- Protect your State Pension entitlement: Claiming ensures you receive National Insurance credits.
- Give your child a National Insurance number: This is needed for future benefits and savings.
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
How do I appeal a high income Child Benefit charge?
Understanding the High Income Child Benefit Charge
- The HICBC is a tax charge for higher earners who receive Child Benefit.
- If your individual income exceeds £50,000, or if you have a partner and your income is the higher of the two, you may have to pay it.
- The charge cancels out the Child Benefit you receive at a rate of 1% of your Child Benefit for every £100 of income over £50,000.
How to Appeal
If you think the HICBC has been applied incorrectly, you have the right to appeal. Here's how:
Contact HMRC:
- Phone: Child Benefit Helpline on 0300 200 3100
- Write to: HMRC, Child Benefit Office, BX9 1AN
- Clearly explain the reason for your appeal and provide supporting evidence (e.g., payslips, tax return, evidence of allowable deductions).
Mandatory Reconsideration: HMRC will review your case. If you're still unsatisfied with their decision, you can request a mandatory reconsideration. This involves a more in-depth review of your situation.
Appeal to the Tribunal: If the mandatory reconsideration doesn't resolve the issue, you have the option to appeal to an independent tribunal (the First-tier Tribunal, Tax Chamber).
Important Points
- You usually have a specific timeframe to appeal, so check your HMRC correspondence.
- You can seek help from organisations like Citizens Advice or TaxAid for guidance.
- Keep records of all communication with HMRC related to the appeal.
For more information, refer to the official government guidance:
- HICBC on GOV.UK: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/high-income-child-benefit-charge-data/high-income-child-benefit-charge
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
What is the penalty for high income Child Benefit charge?
There isn't a direct 'penalty' in the traditional sense for the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC). Instead, the HICBC functions as a tax that gradually reduces, and can entirely remove, your received Child Benefit.
How it works: If one partner in your household has an 'Adjusted Net Income' over £50,000, you'll need to repay part of your Child Benefit. The charge is 1% of your Child Benefit for every £100 of income over that £50,000 threshold. If your income reaches £60,000 or above, you'll repay the entire amount you received.
Payment: You normally pay the HICBC through your Self Assessment tax return.
Important Considerations:
- Opting out: You can choose to stop receiving Child Benefit payments altogether to avoid the HICBC. However, you would lose out on National Insurance credits that protect your State Pension rights.
- Late filing: HMRC can issue penalties if you fail to file your Self Assessment tax return, or pay the charge on time.
For More Information:
- GOV.UK guidance on the High Income Child Benefit Charge: https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-charge
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
What happens to my Child Benefit if I earn over 50k?
If you or your partner earns over £50,000 a year, you'll still receive your Child Benefit payments. However, you may have to pay back some or all of it through a tax charge known as the High Income Child Benefit Tax Charge.
How it works:
- The Charge: For every £100 you earn over £50,000, you'll pay back 1% of your family's total Child Benefit entitlement.
- Who Pays: The person with the highest income in your household is responsible for paying the tax charge.
- Repayment: You'll repay the charge through your Self Assessment tax return.
Example:
If you earn £58,000, you'll be £8,000 over the £50,000 threshold. This means you'll need to pay back 80% of your Child Benefit. If you have two children, you would lose a significant portion of the benefit.
Important Points:
- Even if you have to repay the full Child Benefit amount, it might still be worth claiming it. This helps protect your National Insurance record and future State Pension entitlement.
- You can use the Child Benefit tax calculator on the HMRC website to work out how much you might have to pay back: https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-calculator
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
How can I reduce my high income Child Benefit charge?
The High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) is a tax that applies if you or your partner have an individual income exceeding £50,000 in a tax year. The charge gradually reduces the benefit you receive, and once income exceeds £60,000, the charge equals the full amount of Child Benefit.
How to Reduce the HICBC
Here are several ways to reduce or avoid the High Income Child Benefit Charge:
- Opt out of Child Benefit: This is the most straightforward way to avoid the HICBC. You can still claim Child Benefit but choose not to receive the payments. Your or your partner's National Insurance credits will still be protected so you won't miss out on State Pension contributions.
- Increase pension contributions: Pension contributions reduce your 'adjusted net income', which is the figure used to calculate the HICBC. Increasing your pension contributions can bring your income below the £50,000 threshold or reduce the amount of the charge. You'll also benefit from higher tax relief on your contributions.
- Make charitable donations through Gift Aid: Donations made through Gift Aid also reduce your adjusted net income. The charity will receive an extra 25p from HMRC for every £1 you donate, increasing the impact of your giving.
- Salary sacrifice schemes: If your employer offers them, salary sacrifice schemes (like childcare vouchers) can lower your taxable income. However, many of these schemes are less common now due to changes in tax rules.
- Pay the charge via your tax code: If you can't reduce your taxable income enough, you might be able to arrange for HMRC to collect the charge through your tax code for the following tax year.
Important Considerations
- Both partner's incomes: The charge is based on the higher earner's income in a couple, not combined household income.
- Child Benefit Calculator: Use the official HMRC Child Benefit tax calculator (https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-calculator) to estimate your charge and the potential impact of different strategies.
- It's not always about saving money: Even if you'll pay the charge in full, claiming Child Benefit protects your National Insurance record. This remains crucial for your State Pension entitlement.
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
Do I need to pay high income Child Benefit charge?
Understanding the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC)
The HICBC is a tax charge that may be applied if you or your partner have an individual income exceeding £50,000 during the tax year. It's designed to gradually reduce the amount of Child Benefit you receive as your income increases.
Do you need to pay?
You might need to pay the HICBC if both the following apply:
- Your individual income, or your partner's, is over £50,000.
- You or your partner receives Child Benefit payments.
Important Notes:
- Who pays: The partner with the higher income is liable for the HICBC.
- 'Partner' means: Someone you're married to, in a civil partnership with, or living with as a couple.
- Adjusted Net Income: The HICBC is calculated based on your 'adjusted net income,' which includes salary, taxable benefits, and other forms of income.
How much is the HICBC?
- The charge is 1% of your Child Benefit entitlement for every £100 of income between £50,000 and £60,000.
- If your income exceeds £60,000, the charge equals the full amount of Child Benefit you receive.
How to deal with the HICBC
- Calculate: Use the government's Child Benefit tax calculator to work out if you're liable and the amount: https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-calculator
- Pay: The charge is typically paid through your Self Assessment tax return.
- Opt-out: If you don't want to complete a Self Assessment, you can choose to stop receiving Child Benefit payments, avoiding the charge.
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
Should I apply for Child Benefit even if I earn over 60k?
Here's a breakdown of why you should apply for Child Benefit in the UK even if you earn over £60,000:
Key Reasons:
- National Insurance Credits: Child Benefit helps protect your State Pension entitlement. You'll receive National Insurance credits even if you don't get the payments themselves. This is essential, especially if you are a stay-at-home parent or earn below the National Insurance threshold.
- Child's National Insurance Number: Registering for Child Benefit ensures your child automatically receives a National Insurance number before they turn 16.
- Gateway to Other Benefits: In some situations, having Child Benefit in place can help you qualify for other forms of financial support.
- Changes in Circumstances: Your income might fluctuate in the future. If it drops below £60,000, you can easily start receiving full Child Benefit payments again.
The High-Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC)
If you or your partner earns over £50,000 annually, you'll be subject to the HICBC. This means you'll need to repay a portion (or all) of the Child Benefit through your tax returns. Here's the breakdown
- Income over £60,000: You'll repay the entire Child Benefit amount.
- Income between £50,000 and £60,000: You'll repay a portion of the Child Benefit.
Should you still apply?
Definitely! Even if you have to repay some or all of the Child Benefit, the National Insurance credits and other potential benefits make it worthwhile.
How to Apply
You can apply for Child Benefit on the Gov.UK website (https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit). You can choose to receive the payments or opt out and still secure those important National Insurance credits.
Important Note: Even if you decide not to receive the payments, it's crucial to register for Child Benefit to get the advantages mentioned above.
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
How do I avoid the high income Child Benefit charge?
What is the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC)?
The HICBC is a tax charge in the UK for individuals whose 'adjusted net income' exceeds £50,000 in a tax year. The charge gradually claws back the Child Benefit received, reaching 100% when your income is £60,000 or above.
How to Avoid the High Income Child Benefit Charge
There are several strategies you can use to avoid or reduce the HICBC:
- Opting Out of Child Benefit: The simplest way to avoid the HICBC is to stop receiving Child Benefit payments altogether. However, remember that you may lose valuable National Insurance credits which affect your State Pension entitlement. You can still claim and then opt-out by contacting HMRC (see https://www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-charge/stop-child-benefit)
- Reducing Your Taxable Income: If your 'adjusted net income' is just over the £50,000 threshold, reducing it below this level will eliminate the charge. Methods include:
- Pension Contributions: Increase your pension contributions, as these are deducted from your income before tax. You'll benefit from tax relief, and your pension savings will grow.
- Salary Sacrifice Schemes: If your employer offers them, participate in schemes like childcare vouchers or cycle-to-work, as these reduce your taxable income.
- Gift Aid Donations: Charitable donations made through Gift Aid reduce your taxable income.
- Income Splitting: If you're in a partnership and one partner earns slightly over the threshold, consider ways to shift some income to the lower-earning partner (but be aware of tax rules around income shifting).
Important Considerations
- Calculating Your Adjusted Net Income: Your 'adjusted net income' includes salary, taxable benefits, investment income, and rental income. Make sure you do the calculations correctly.
- The Charge is Per Individual: Each person exceeding the £50,000 threshold must pay the HICBC based on their individual income, not household income.
- Long-Term Financial Planning: These strategies can have broader implications for your finances. Seek professional financial advice if you're unsure about the best choices for your situation.
Child Benefit Accountants Chester
Accountants Chester: Boost Your Business with Expert Support!
Get a FREE Consultation & Tailored Accounting Solutions
Call/WhatsApp: +44(1244) 220-062
Disclaimer
The information contained in this blog is for general guidance only. It does not constitute professional advice and should not be relied upon as such. Always seek tailored advice from a qualified accountant regarding your specific circumstances.